Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


Paradise Stolen

by rcs1

with help from cho and jenn718

Who will speak for the Hawaiian People ...

An appointment postponed gave me the opportunity to do something I had not planned. On the spur of the moment, instead of heading into Honolulu to the Capital Building, I headed the other way to Nanakuli on the leeward shore of Oahu to snap a few pictures. The leeward side of Oahu is home to some of the most beautiful beaches on the island. Just North of the Ko'Olina Resort [pictured to the right] - a bastion of pompous wealth, complete with yacht club, golf courses and elite tourists - lie the beaches of Nanakuli and Waianae, a stark contrast of apparent poverty, and home to many native Hawaiians.

Being new to the island, I am haole. Haole is not a derogatory term; it means simply "no breath."* In the old days, the customary greeting among the Hawaiian people was to rub noses and share breath. Foreigners did not adopt this custom, so were called "haole." I had been warned that it was not "safe" for a "haole" to venture among the residents of Nanakuli and Waianae, so I had planned on just stopping briefly, snapping the pictures, and moving along. There is good reason to understand why the native Hawaiians would harbor deep resentment against outsiders, as they have been betrayed and abused for two centuries by the "haoles" that landed on their shores ... but we will talk about that later.


commentary :: :: :: buzz-it!

Ohana Means Family

My daughter and I drove along the road, and would slow or stop to snap pictures, but we just couldn't get the pictures we wanted, so we pulled onto a side road that ran along the beach. As we stopped the car , we were greeted by a local pushing an empty baby stroller along. She greeted us warmly in the spirit of old Hawaii with "ohana" and "aloha." Bobbi, a woman of indeterminate age, with young skin and grey hair, is one of the Hawaiians that lives in this village on the beach. I explained to Bobbi that we were taking some pictures for an article I was writing for an online journal. She got very excited ... and invited us into her camp. She was not only willing to share her experiences with us but called others – Susie, Nick and Dennis -- to the table to share with us as well.

What occurred next was humbling and uplifting at the same time and inexpressible. My first impression as I looked around, was, here are people with nothing. But that was my impression when I arrived; by the time I left, I was just beginning to understand that these people were rich in ways that we have a hard time understanding. Not only were they rich, they had enriched my life in an indefinable way. There is much talk in Hawaiian political circles about "cleaning up the beach." But as we looked around, the beach was clean ... free of garbage and debris, with only a lone hot pink surfboard standing in the sand accenting the pristine beauty of the ocean view. It’s obvious that "cleaning up the beach" really translates into moving these people into homeless shelters: All for their own good, mind you, but never-the-less against their will.

As we sat there listening to Bobbi and her friend Susie talk about their lives, I realized that just because we haoles think we know what is best for them, nobody has listened to them. Bobbie says "Nobody speaks for us," and Susie chimes in "We are just Social Security Numbers."

I want to speak for them. I am not an eloquent writer, and but I can only hope that a small fraction of what I am feeling in my heart will come across in these words.

A Brief History

The Great King Kamahemaha the First welcomed all to the shores of his island paradise. To perpetuate this philosophy, there are no "private" beaches in Hawaii, yet, perversely, these Hawaiian people are being forced from the beaches into homeless shelters. They aren't homeless, they are home. As Bobbi observed, she has a beachfront home, and she swept her arm to encompass the ocean ... "Why would I want to move into a cage?"

They are happy with their life -- and their way of life. Who are we to decide what is best for them?

The shores of Nanakuli and Waianae are "sacred" in the ancient Hawaiian tradition. Just a short distance up the road is Kaneana, where all life is said to have come from.

    Kaneana is a sacred "ana" (cave) that ancient Hawaiians named after Kane, the God of Creation. From inside the depth of Kaneana, symbolic of the earth goddess's womb, mankind emerged and his existence spread throughout the Waianae coast. The souls of those who passed on go to Kalae O Kala'au (Ka'ena Point). From there souls ascend to Po, the realm of ancestral spirits, completing the cycle of life. -- taken from the placard in front of the cave

It has been a standard of Manifest Destiny to not only conquer an indigenous people, but to ensure their integration into the mainstream of capitalistic society by removing their belief systems and "educating" their children. This education includes -- but is not limited to -- the subjugation of their native tongue and the conversion to a more acceptable belief system -- namely Christianity (or in the case of the Hawaiian people, Mormonism and Catholicism).

Until 1893, Hawaii was ruled by a monarchy, with the last of this line being Queen Liliuokalani. The Queen's story is an incredibly sad tale, as she was imprisoned in her palace to keep her from bearing heirs as Sanford Dole usurped power and declared himself President of the Hawaiian Republic. In 1900 Hawaii became a Territory of the United States and Sanford Dole was sworn in as Governor.

From 1779 when Captain James Cooke, the first "haole," landed on the shores of Big Island, until today, the Hawaiian people have resisted the encroachment of the haoles and their business interests. Yet, 228 years later, these Hawaiian people on the beaches of Nanakuli welcomed us into their homes, with open arms and aloha. These people with no material wealth shared what little wealth they did have.

As Bobbi and I discussed some of the history of the islands, she talked about books she had, and before I left her, she made them a gift to me. For her, though tattered and dog-eared, they are treasures without price and she presented them to me with great pride. These people are not asking for anything. They don't want a hand-out and they most certainly don't want to be taken care of ... all they want is to be allowed to live, to be.

Is it really too much to ask, after all we have taken from them?

For the Hawaiian people, these islands are truly, Paradise Lost.

Notes

*There is some disagreement as to the true derivative meaning of haole, but I will go with this.

Display:
I am already curious as to how women were treated.  Equality....are all men and women treated equally in their culture?  

I'm ready for more of the story...!!!!

by avahome on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 02:19:46 PM EST

Good backgrounder:  Hawaii Nation.org is one of the groups advocating for a return to sovereignty.  Some efforts to return at least a portion of the islands has been successful over the past few years, and small gains are being made against "big money" development.  (A $500 million development was successfully challenged on the Big Island (Kona side), while the geothermal plants were approved (Puna side).

Yes indeedy, paradise close-to-lost.  But just like the Black Hills, extremely difficult to restore to "original condition".

by rba on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 02:21:05 PM EST

a solution is very hard to find ... The Akaka Bill addresses some of the issues ... will write more on this later. :)

by roxy317 on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 02:29:44 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I hope there will be more to come from your visit with your new friends.  

by standingup on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 06:20:50 PM EST
There is no recommend button on this! Oh wait! There is a Buzz it! button... Be back later.

Guaranteed to be plastered all over the Internet
Drinking Liberally in New Milford
by Connecticut Man1 on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 11:19:04 PM EST
I've lived in Waianae for 7 years and I have personally seen it all.  I've met many homeless on the beaches, and some of my closest friends are there.  I have a sincere love for the Hawaiian people, but not all of the homeless are Hawaiian.

Hawaii is paradise and the climate is like nothing else in the USA.  Anyone can live comfortably outdoors, and specifically on the beach parks.  Waianae gets very few storms, and has some of the best and most beautiful beaches on Oahu.  There is free access to water, showers, toilets and all that.  So now our homeless population has grown into the thousands.  Spread out throughout the entire coastline.  Most receive welfare aid.  Unfortunately because they have nothing to do, most get or are very addicted to drugs.  It's there, all around them.  When they work jobs, they do much better, they're healthier, productive and this comes from their own mouths.  In other words, it's uplifting to be trusted and given an opportunity.  We have to have more programs for them. Ice, the worst kind of drug is what most use.  It deteriorates their minds and body completely.  

Now let's say you live on the west side, you and your family want to go swimming and spend a day soaking up rays.  Well, guess what?  You car is at VERY high risk of getting broken into.  I know because mine has been broken into "two times" and I don't even drive to the beach all that often.  If you can't be watching your car from where you are sitting, you can very well get a surprise.  It happens daily on a regular basis.  As a matter of fact, my little brother had his clothing and shoes stolen on the beach last month, right off his towel.  

Our taxes are so high now that the mortgage is $200 more since early 2005, and yet we can't enjoy our beach parks or go camping.  Why are tax paying residents being punished?  Many are Hawaiian, so why can't we help them progress.  Sitting around with nothing to do or doing drugs isn't good for anyone.  Give them low cost or even free housing, help them thrive in there communities.  Get them on there feet.  Give them a chance to have it all in a healthy and kind manner.  Give Natives more program privileges.
 

by Koko on Thu Aug 23, 2007 at 11:56:11 PM EST

I understand everything you are saying and have talked to locals that feel the same way you do. As this series progresses I hope to explore all sides of the issue.

The problems with crime and drugs you talk about are everywhere, not just here.  I have had my car broken into and stuff stolen while at a State Park in Oregon ... we were just down at the lake soaking up rays and somebody broke into my car.  Same lake -- different trip we had our cooler stolen while we were swimming.

We have taken several day trips to Kaneana and picnicked on the beach ... car was fine.  

Drugs and alcohol abuse are unfortunately a big problem, not just here in Hawaii and not just among native populations. It is a symptom of a much larger social problem.  

I don't even pretend to have the answer, but I don't think "more welfare" is the right approach either.

by roxy317 on Fri Aug 24, 2007 at 01:09:30 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Roxy, I never claimed to have the answer.  Read my full post, the first was cut off.  

You obviously need to really do some research.  You can't compare oregon to our crime and homeless problem in Waianae.  There's nothing like this.  

Do me a favor and don't take sides until you really know what's going on.  

This was in today's news: http://www.khnl.com/Global/story.asp?S=6991211

Check it out.

by Koko on Wed Aug 29, 2007 at 05:05:19 AM EST
[ Parent ]

I've lived in Waianae for 7 years and I have personally seen it all.  I've met many homeless on the beaches, and some of my closest friends are there.  I have a sincere love for the Hawaiian people, but not all of the homeless are Hawaiian.

Hawaii is paradise and the climate is like nothing else in the USA.  Anyone can live comfortably outdoors, and specifically on the beach parks.  There is free access to water, showers, toilets and all that.  So now our homeless population has grown into the thousands.  Spread out throughout the entire coastline.  Most receive welfare aid.  Unfortunately because they have nothing to do, most get or are very addicted to drugs.  It's there, all around them.  When they work jobs, they do much better, they're healthier, productive and this comes from their own mouths.  In other words, it's uplifting to be trusted and given an opportunity.  We have to have more programs for them. Ice, the worst kind of drug is what most use.  It deteriorates their minds and body completely.  

Now let's say you live on the west side, you and your family want to go swimming and spend a day soaking up rays.  Well, guess what?  You car is at VERY high risk of getting broken into.  I know because mine has been broken into "two times" and I don't even drive to the beach all that often.  If you can't be watching your car from where you are sitting, you can very well get a surprise.  It happens daily on a regular basis.  As a matter of fact, my little brother had his clothing and shoes stolen on the beach last month, right off his towel.  

Our taxes are so high now that the mortgage is $200 more since early 2005, and yet we can't enjoy our beach parks or go camping.  Why are tax paying residents being punished?  Many are Hawaiian, so why can't we help them progress.  Sitting around with nothing to do or doing drugs isn't good for anyone.  Give them low cost or even free housing, help them thrive in there communities.  Get them on there feet.  Give them a chance to have it all in a healthy and kind manner.  Give Natives more program privileges.

Roxy, if you get to go back and explore more, take me with you.  I can introduce you to endless amounts of homeless on the Waianae coast.  I've given several of them small kine work in and around my home for years.  "All" of my hand me downs go to Waianae's homeless.  Specifically, Pokai Bay, Sewers (everyone calls it that, across the sewer plant), before the sweep Maili beach park, and a few in betweens.  I've also feed some.  I try and do what little I can.  Unfortunately it is not enough.  I want and wish I could do more.  Lingle promises to respond to every email she receives from Hawaii residents, but unfortunately I haven't received one response out of 3 letters.  
 

by Koko on Fri Aug 24, 2007 at 12:02:26 AM EST

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |