Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


A rose for their graves ...

by rcs1

Penny Coleman is the author of Flashback -- reviewed here

It is only recently that I have come to think of myself as a war widow.

First published on AlterNet as
The casualties continue to mount after they come home ...

at 11:05 AM on May 28, 2007.


commentary :: :: :: buzz-it!
  • David Fickel, a 25-year-old Minnesotan honorably discharged from the Marine Corps after serving in Iraq, used a shotgun to take his own life on Memorial Day, 2006
  • Linda Michel, a 33-year-old Navy medic from Albany, who served at a U.S.-run prison near Baghdad, returned to her husband and three children last October and, two weeks later, shot and killed herself
  • Jonathan Schulze, a 25-year-old from New Prague, MN, asked to be admitted to a VA hospital on January 11 because he was thinking of killing himself. Told he was No. 26 on the waiting list, he hung himself at his parents' farm, leaving behind his pregnant wife and a young daughter

  • Michael Bramer, a 23-year-old from Boston who had served with the Army's 82d Airborne Division, turned up the surround sound on his television on January 17 and took his own life
  • Jessica Rich, a 24-year-old Army Reservist and mother of a 7-year-old son, despaired of leaving behind her nightmares and flashbacks of Iraq. On February 8, she drove her car into oncoming traffic on I-25 outside of Denver and died
  • Chris Dana, a 23-year-old Iraq war veteran from Helena who friends said wore his uniform and boots for weeks at a time, even to sleep, shut himself in his bedroom in March, put a blanket over his head, and shot himself
It is only recently that I have come to think of myself as a war widow. When my husband Daniel came home from Vietnam in 1970, the relationship between combat-related stress and suicide was officially unrecognized. When Daniel took his own life, it never occurred to me to blame the war. I thought that if only I had been kinder, more patient, more vigilant, I might have prevented his death. The shame and guilt on top of my grief were a terrible burden. It was decades before I could find some compassion and forgiveness for that young woman who had no idea what she was up against.

In the years since Daniel's death, there has been a steady stream of reports, many from mainstream sources, claiming shocking numbers of suicides among Vietnam veterans. Rather than tracking or investigating those claims, the government has first refused to investigate and then used the lack of evidence to argue that the claims were untrue.

That disingenuous stance mirrors the current official response. While a mental health advisory team was sent to Iraq in 2003 to investigate alarming reports of suicides among American troops, the team concluded that soldiers were killing themselves, not because of the horrors of combat, but for what was labeled "underdeveloped life coping skills". The Army's Surgeon General told "Stars and Stripes" in December that he had "no evidence linking suicides with multiple deployments or Post Traumatic Stress Disorder" "(W)e've had young soldiers," he elaborated, "who will get bad relationship news and walk right into a Porta-Potty and end their lives."

Since 2003, the suicide rate for active-duty soldiers has continued to rise. The Army camouflages the real numbers as non-combat-related accidents. Veterans' suicides are not included on official casualty lists because they are not considered service-related deaths.

This administration's policies regarding PTSD and combat-related suicide are consistent with their claims to support the troops while making budgetary decisions that endanger them. In the past six years, more than 22,500 soldiers, most diagnosed with PTSD or traumatic brain injury, have been dismissed from service with a diagnosis of "personality disorder," which, considered a pre-existing condition, absolves the VA of all responsibility for their future care. Despite cries of foul from psychiatrists, veterans' rights groups, injured soldiers and their families, and even the military officials required to process these dismissals, the practice continues and successful appeals are almost non-existent. "The Army Times" reports a backlog of some 600,000 veterans' benefits claims on appeal. On average, it takes the VA 177 days to process an original claim and 657 days to process an appeal. If psychically injured veterans die with their case under appeal, the case dies with them.

Last week, a report from the inspector general of Veterans Affairs finally acknowledged that veterans are at increased risk of suicide. Multiple and extended deployments are causing more psychological problems that become lethal in the absence of available care when they return. If we are to prevent another epidemic of death like that which followed the war in Vietnam, the VA health care system must provide immediate and quality care for our veterans. Cheating citizens who have risked their lives for their country out of promised and desperately needed benefits will surely save the government billions of dollars. Just as surely, it will push too many past the limits of their despair.

As we remember our war dead on this Memorial Day, let us include the tens of thousands of Vietnam veterans whose names are not on the Memorial Wall and the soldiers and veterans of these current wars whose psychic injuries have proved every bit as deadly as any bullet or bomb. David Fickel, Zackery Bowen, Linda Michel, Jonathan Schulze, Michael Bramer, Jessica Rich, and my husband Daniel are not just statistics. Their deaths were personal tragedies, but they are also cautionary tales

Penny Coleman is the widow of a Vietnam Veteran who took his own life after coming home. Her latest book, Flashback: Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, Suicide and the Lessons of War, was released on Memorial Day, 2006 (Beacon Press).

Display:
You remind me that even though we though the Bush administration is following in the footsteps of previous administrations with veterans, we do have the benefit of knowledge and information that was not there for those in the Vietnam war.  It's difficult to say that is much of an advantage yet I hope it gives us a jump start in pushing for more help for the veterans of the Iraq war.  We have to do better this time around.  

by standingup on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 02:27:44 PM EST
A war is never over for its participants--and they bring it home to their families, whether they want to or not.

Thanks for helping us learn.

by Aaron Barlow on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 04:57:38 PM EST

I was a young Marine in Vietnam a few years older than Daniel and a few years earlier.

I came home, I am so sorry that he did not.

I excerpted this at my site, you tell a story that badly needs telling and being heard.

Thank you

Bob

by BobHiggins on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 07:42:39 PM EST

Thank you, Bob, for the posting and for the comments. I have something I would love to talk over with you if you have a minute.

by Penny on Mon Jun 25, 2007 at 02:39:36 PM EST
[ Parent ]
it's an amazing book. What shocked me was that after WWI, II and Korea -- in every case -- the army brass and psychiatrists understood better ways to treat PTSD, and yet by the first years of each new war, Iraq included, there's is denial and complete amnesia and a bully attitude that creates an entire new generation of victims.

by Cho on Sat Jun 23, 2007 at 07:53:01 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |