Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


The Iraq Study Group Grope

by rcs1

Cross posted at the front pages of Pen and Sword and My Left Wing. Also at Kos.

The Iraq Study Group (ISG) report is on the street.  

There is no magic formula.  We need a bipartisan approach.  The situation in Iraq is grave and deteriorating.  The challenges are complex.  Violence is increasing.  The elected Iraqi government is not adequately advancing national reconciliation, providing basic security or delivering essential services. Pessimism is pervasive.  

Great Prescott Bush's Ghost!  This ten member blue ribbon committee worked for 9 months to tell young Mister Bush and the American public things my dogs already know?  


commentary :: :: :: buzz-it!
At least the ISG said in public things that needed to be said, and there's something to be said for that.  

They also made some bold suggestions; among the best of them was to engage Iran and Syria constructively.  The ISG is hardly the first group to say this, but it certainly helps that they've thrown their weight behind the proposal.

And they made a long needed condemnation of the Bush administration's diplomacy record: f

Iraq's neighbors and much of the international community have not been persuaded to play an active and constructive role in supporting Iraq. The ability of the United States to shape outcomes is diminishing. Time is running out.

"Time is running out" may be an optimistic assessment.  

Young Mister Bush: Taking It Like a Boy

Whatever else it may or may not have accomplished, the ISG took an overdue paddle to 60 old Mister Bush's behind.  His foreign policy has failed, so badly that there may not be a way to fix the situation in Iraq and the Middle East.  

At a Wednesday morning press conference Press Conference, ISG members were remarkably candid during the question and answer session.  

Former Congressman and member of the 9/11 Commission Lee Hamilton confessed that it may already be too late for the ISG's recommendations to be effective. "From the very beginning we recognized that events could overtake our work, could overtake policy, American policy in the region. And that may still be the case."  What might those events be?  "Anarchy, total chaos, the collapse of the government without a new government taking its place and rampant violence throughout the country."

Many would argue that those events are already taking place.

Leon Panetta, President Clinton's former Chief of staff, said, "I think we owe it to [the Iraqis] to try to take one last chance at making Iraq work and, more importantly, to take one last chance at unifying this country on this war. I think the president understands that he simply is not going to be able to proceed with whatever policy changes he wants to implement if we're divided."

That sounded to me like Panetta telling Sonny that he's got one last chance to get his head unscrewed from wherever it's buried or he's tomorrow's breakfast special at Denny's.

Hamilton, Panetta and former Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor made a point of saying that ISG has no statutory authority, and that having completed its work, no longer exists as an advisory body.

In naval aviator-ese, this translates into: "Told ya.  See ya.  Sure hate to be ya."  

Several ISG members alluded to bipartisanship in Congress and the role of the press in pulling the country together, but it was clear that real focus of their remarks was the Commander in Chief, and the message was "The bus you hear roaring down the street has your name on it."

How will Bush take all this?  All the unflattering psychological profiles of him that I've read and heard resonate, but I've given up trying to figure out what, if anything, is going on between the guy's ears, or who--besides Karl Rove, Dick Cheney, and his God--he listens to anymore.  

When Mister Bush finally decides to publicly address the ISG report, listen closely to what he says, and see if it sounds any different than anything you've heard from him in the past six years.  My best guess and worst fear is that his spin masters will search the ISG's report and press conference transcript for the most convenient lever they can find to discredit it, and I'll bet you a Coca Cola that here's what they'll come up with for Mister Bush's speech:

"ISG Chairman Jim Baker himself said that the approach his committee recommended has its shortcomings ..."

Anybody care to take me up on that bet?

In Other News...

Forget about the danger of Cheney talking Bush into launching another unprovoked attack on Iran for the sake of keeping a stranglehold on the world's energy market.  That's small potatoes compared to the latest news from NASA.

NASA's Mars rovers, which have been exploring the planet's surface since they landed there in 2004, have found strong evidence that suggests that water flowed on the planet long ago.

Holy simoleons!  If there was water on Mars, that means there was life there once, which means there's oil under the planet's surface.

Stand by for a national mobilization to combat the Axis of Extraterrestial Evil.  

Wanted Dead or Alive: al-Ming the Merciless.

Despite urging by the Interplanetary Study Group, don't expect the Bush administration to engage in direct diplomatic talks with Venus or Jupiter, which Condi Rice's State Department is about to identify as "rogue planets."

#

Commander Jeff Huber, U.S. Navy (Retired) writes from Virginia Beach, Virginia.  Read his commentaries at Pen and Sword.

Display:
Apart from being in general, even admirable agreement, my hope this Wednesday evening, for what it is worth, is that there is still a way to number 1 get back to having some kind of diplomatic/political approach to foreign policy, number 2 having a diplomatic/political approach to the whole region, and all its accumulated 'problems', and number 3 that "everything is on the table,no option is ruled out" no longer be the US answer to every foreign policy issue that comes up, it is time that one got put back in its box for a while. If those things can look like they might happen, and then begin to happen, allowing for all the provisos about who is in charge, and how it won't work, it may be possible for useful things to happen despite what everyone knows and fears, just because everything is so darn fubar and everyone knows it, except for the noted exceptions.

by Chris White on Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 09:09:04 PM EST
Still singing their song but they are all doin' it in a different key and the noise is as discordant as it gets.

I listened to the ISG press briefing after watching the downbeat Bush statement earlier in the day. Then on came singing all the talking heads and Richard Perle appeared on the BBC.

I listened to Prime Minister's Question Time in Parliament when Blair accepted the truth about Iraq without a sign of embarrassment or remorse as if he had been saying it for month's and wasn't a complete turnaround:

DAVID CAMERON: The new US Defence Secretary said we were not winning the war in Iraq. Does the Prime Minister share that very serious assessment?

TONY BLAIR: Of course. In July I said myself that the situation in Baghdad, with sectarian killing, was appalling, and that the bloodshed was appalling. And what is important, however, is, as he went on to say, is that we do go on to succeed in the mission that we have set ourselves.

So I look for a different sound now about the war after four years of waiting and ten more US deaths today after the thousands and thousands of deaths.

Yet I still have to hear Reyes talking of wanting more troops in there and from everyone else blather, blather blather around and past and above the truth of Iraq.

And my country music station is still playing this evening Toby Keith's Red, White and Blue:

Justice will be served
And the battle will rage
This big dog will fight
When you rattle his cage
And youll be sorry that you messed with
The u.s. of a.
cause well put a boot in your ass
Its the american way

Hey uncle sam
Put your name at the top of his list
And the statue of liberty
Started shakin her fist
And the eagle will fly
Man, its gonna be hell
When you hear mother freedom
Start ringin her bell
And it feels like the whole wide world is raining down on you
Brought to you courtesy of the red white and blue

I thought the people had spoken?  Well, it is not the Statue of Liberty's fist that is shaking.

It is all of us hearing the disconnect of the sounds around us. Great music alone does not make a great song.

(Nor does a panel of elder statespeople sing a good song, when they tell us at the top of the briefing this morning how grave, how serious, how dangerous a situation is but, hey, they held off revealing it "because of the mid-terms".

It made the press briefing just one more piece of ugly dischord as soon as this was said in a way that suggested we should bow in awe at their bi-partisan congressional wisdom. Every mother of every American dead and every mother of every Iraqi dead that were made to wait for their carefully politically nuanced report should be screaming.)


by Welshman on Wed Dec 06, 2006 at 11:07:56 PM EST

The decider didn't hear them.

by Jeff Huber on Thu Dec 07, 2006 at 10:42:47 AM EST

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |