Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


Tan Nguyen and the racist right. CA-47

by rcs1

originally published -- Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 02:34:42 AM EST, bumped, promoted --cho

Thirty-six hours ago Tan Nguyen was a little know Republican congressional candidate from Orange County CA with no chance of winning and no prospect of ever garnering national attention. That was before it came to light that he was most likely behind a failed effort to intimidate Hispanic voters  in hopes of deterring them from showing up at the polls. With that one move, he now becomes the newest poster boy in an election season ripe with disclosures of Republican racism and malfeasance.

The revelations of George Allen's bigotry and hidden past of racist activity shed new light on the undercurrent of racism that has run through Republican politics for years. Yet, Nguyen represents a new, and perhaps more toxic, kind of Republican; those drawn into politics by the volatile issue of immigration.  With its ability divide people along the lines of race and ethnicity, the immigration "issue" has drawn a new breed of activists and politicians.  These new "movement racists," with ties to organized hate groups, are bent on dragging both their party and the nation down a path of intolerance and bigotry not seen before.


commentary :: :: :: buzz-it!
Earlier this week, in a mailing printed on the letterhead of the controversial Huntington Beach anti-immigration group, California Coalition for Immigration Reform, 14,000 Hispanic residents in centrarange County were warned that going to the polls could result in their possible deportation.

You are advised that if your residence in this country is illegal or you are an immigrant, voting in a federal election is a crime that could result in jail time, and you will be deported for voting without having a right to do so.

At the same time, you are advised that the government of the United States is installing a new computer system to verify the names of all new registered voters that vote in the October and November elections. Anti-immigration organizations can ask for information from this new computer system.

Link English

Original in Spanish



CCIR, founder, Barbara Coe who has referred to Mexican immigrants as "savages" and "illegal barbarians who are cutting off heads and appendages of blind, white, disabled gringos" denied orchestrating the letter and said she had no knowledge of it's alleged author "Sergio Ramirez,"

Upon further investigation, the letter, which contains grammatical errors that led investigators to believe it was not written by a native Spanish speaker, was found to have originated the offices of Tan Nguyen.

The bulk mail permit used to send out the letter was sent by a Huntington Beach-based company named Mailing Pros. Nguyen's campaign used the company for five different mailers this year, with several highlighting immigration issues, according to campaign finance disclosures.

Christopher West, who owns the company, said he was interviewed for two hours by investigators from the State Attorney General's office. He would not publicly disclose who hired him, although he gave the information to investigators. West said he had no idea any laws were being broken when the mailer was sent.

"I'm the one that processed it and I don't read Spanish, until the investigator read it to me, I didn't know the content," West said.

West said his company sends out many mailers in at least a dozen languages that he does not speak.

"The thing that steams me out about this is I know damn well I didn't do anything wrong," he said. "You're dependent on the integrity of the candidates."

According to campaign finance disclosures, Nguyen's campaign also has contracted with the Burbank-based Political Data Inc. for data sorts from the Registrar of Voters database. Records show the company purchased an Orange County voter database in September, which could show addresses of every foreign-born voter in the county, the target group of the mailer. Company officials couldn't be reached for comment.

Orange County Register



In a written statement, Nguyen denied personal responsibility for the letter claiming, "Evidently, an employee took it upon herself to allow our database to be used to send out the letter. It was disseminated without my authorization or approval. The employee has been discharged."

But Orange County GOP Chairman Scott Baugh disputes Nguyen's claim and has called for his withdrawal from the race. "I've learned that Mr. Nguyen was involved in expediting that mailer," Baugh said. "I've had conversations with the attorney general and folks involved with the mail house. He called the mail house himself and told them to expedite the mailing."

This should come as no surprise given the people Nguyen has chosen to associate with.  

His senior adviser, former Orange County Republican Party Chair, Tom Fuentes, has a long history of anti-immigrant advocacy and orchestrating dirty tricks designed to suppress the Latino vote. In addition to being a moving force behind California's failed proposition 187 (along with Barbara Coe), in 1988 he caused a major controversy when he ordered the stationing of Republican poll guards to stand outside polling places in Latino neighborhoods during a local Assembly race.

1988 - In California, the Orange County Republican Party hired uniformed security guards to be posted at polling places in heavily Latino precincts. The guards displayed bilingual signs warning non-citizens not to vote, and such signs were also posted in Latino neighborhoods days before the election. The guards, wearing blue uniforms and badges, were removed from the polling places after the chief deputy secretary of state said their presence was "unlawful intimidation of voters."

The GOP officials involved in the plan, working on the campaign of GOP state assembly candidate Curt Pringle, claimed they acted on rumors that there was illegal registration of voters. However, according to the Orange County Register, they admitted they had no evidence of such activity and were concerned because of a sudden surge in voter registration in some Latino neighborhoods. Many local Latino Republican officials were outraged. GOP Santa Ana councilman John Acosta said: "This has to be the most blatant method of intimidating that I have ever seen. ... It's un-American and I would say it borders on Nazism."

As the controversy grew, the county registrar of voters said that he had warned Republican officials four weeks before the election not to challenge voters at the polls.

In 1989, the Orange County GOP paid $400,000 to settle a lawsuit stemming from the program. The plaintiffs donated $150,000 of the settlement to nonpartisan Latino voter registration efforts in the area. They also released some evidence gathered during the trial, including a map given to a sign-making company by the GOP campaign that indicated intended sign placement. Signs reading "Thank You Curt Pringle" were to go in predominantly white areas and bilingual signs saying "Non Citizens Can't Vote" were to be placed in largely Latino areas.

PFAW



Even with Fuentes involvement, this could all perhaps be chalked up to an extreme case of "dirty politics as usual" if it were not for the fact that like many other "border security" Republicans, Nguyen's ties to his party are tenuous at best and his strongest allies and supporters come not from the mainstream Republican Party, but rather the extremist, anti-immigrant right.

Groups like Coe's CCIR, the Minutemen and Save Our State.

Save Our State, the Ventura California based anti-immigration group founded by Joe Turner has been called a "Trojan Horse" for Neo-Nazis and white supremacists by the Southern Poverty Law Center.

Anti-immigration activist Joe Turner may be one of the best things to happen to the Southern California white power community in years -- a man whose group is seen as a "Trojan horse" allowing radical infiltration of mainstream politics....

In rally after rally this year, Turner and other SOS officials have failed to turn away racist Skinheads and likeminded white supremacists who have joined their protests.

Swastikas and sieg heils aren't usually welcome on the streets of Southern California, but Turner's followers, including SOS spokesman Don Silva, have been photographed standing alongside Skinheads clad in high black boots with red laces. Most recently, swastika pennants and Confederate battle flags were hoisted alongside Turner's own picket signs during a July 30 protest outside a day laborer center in Laguna Beach. One group in the crowd sieg-heiled repeatedly....

And then there are Turner's own statements in his forum. "I am sick and tired of all the white bashing that goes on through the use of political correctness as an indoctrinating tool," he wrote on July 16.

"I am sick and tired of multiculturalism, meaning, let's celebrate every culture as long as it isn't a European/white culture." During the same exchange, Turner also wrote that "just because one believes in white separatism that does not make them a racist."

SPLC " Immigration protesters joined by neo-Nazis in California"



Despite SOS's ties to both white supremacists and neo-Nazi groups, Nguyen chose to court the radical group.

In July of this year Nguyen's campaign manager, Ryan S.Flynn  sent a letter to SOS introducing his candidate and asked the group for their support. It was posted up on the SOS internet forum, where it received a warm reception

Greetings!

I'm writing to introduce Tan Nguyen and ask for your help. Tan is a candidate for Congress of California's 47th district. Tan, a LEGAL immigrant from Vietnam, believes in upholding our immigration laws and opposes anything which encourages illegal immigration.

We need your help in defeating the incumbent, Loretta Sanchez, a seasoned politician who is for Amnesty. Those who donate $20 or more to the campaign will receive one of our campaign signs, shown below. Please help Tan's efforts by forwarding this email to your friends & family.

Checks can be made payable to Tan Nguyen for Congress. Thank you for your support.

Ryan S. Flynn

Campaign Manager/Fundraising Chair

Tan Nguyen for Congress

12955 Main Street

Garden Grove, CA 92840

(714) 530-1612

www.tanforcongress.com



A month earlier on that same forum a member called "minutemanIII" stated that he/she was "helping out Tan Nguyen in Orange County run for Congress in the 47th district." and requested information about an anti-immigration rally SOS was planning.

Nguyen also courted the CCIR

Although Barbara Coe denies any knowledge of Nguyen's  letter, she, like her friends at SOS,  is well aware of the man, having had him speak to her group a year ago... long before he was his parties candidate for the 47th Congresional District. The press release for the October 2005 event called Nguyen  a  "man who believes in America as a "nation of law", has made a commitment to uphold and defend our Constitutional rights and freedoms, has courageously publicly praised the Minuteman Project and publicly opposed any illegal alien "guest-worker" program or amnesty..."

Nguyen is not the fist "Border Security" Republican to court organized racists.

Godfather of the "Border Security" Republicans, Tom Tancredo, has had long standing ties with both the Minutemen and their more radical allies. Back in September, while feeling out a run for the White House, he stood on a stage draped in confederate flags, in South Carolina, with the members of the League of the South, and sang "Dixie" after delivering a speech to the hate group about the need to stop illegal immigration.

In Arizona's 8th congressional district Minuteman, Randy Graf, is running for congress on the Republican ticket having been endorsed by none other than  former Grand Wizard of the Klu Klux Klan, David Duke.

Also in Arizona, State Legislator, Russell Pearce, that states leading Border Security Republican  and author of numerous pieces of anti-immigrant legislation including Proposition 200, sent out a piece of campaign literature to his constituents that contained an  article from the white supremacist group the National Alliance.

Titled "Who Rules America? The Alien Grip on Our News and Entertainment Media Must Be Broken," the article criticized the media for promoting multiculturalism and racial equality, for portraying "any racially conscious White Person" as a bigot and for presenting the Jewish Holocaust as fact.

The media presents a "single view of the world - a world in which every voice proclaims the equality of the races, the inerrant nature of the Jewish 'Holocaust' tale, the wickedness of attempting to halt the flood of non-White aliens pouring across our borders, the danger of permitting citizens to keep and bear arms, the moral equivalence of all sexual orientations, and the desirability of a 'pluralistic,' cosmopolitan society rather than a homogeneous, White one," the article says.

link

Nguyen and the other "movement racists" within the Republican Party who have allied themselves with the likes of Barbara Coe, Joe Turner and Jim Gilchrist represent an insidious and frightening new trend in politics.

Never before have such extreme fringes of society been sought out as political allies and patrons. Yet under the leadership of Tom Tancredo and Pat Buchanan, these new "movement racists" are willing to consort with the anyone who is willing to take up their cause ... even those who only do so as a stepping stone to gain legitimacy and acceptance of their extreme and dangerous beliefs.

Using the Trojan Horse of "border security" and the "immigration crisis" as their means to enter the body politic, these "movement racists" and their radical allies can only take this nation further down a path of division and hate.

The New York Times reports that: "Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger called the letter racist and urged Bill Lockyer, the California attorney general, to prosecute those responsible with a hate crime. A collection of other civil rights groups also called on Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales to investigate the letter as a violation of federal voting laws." Let's hope they follow through with their prosecution. The time to stop this movement is now.... before it's too late


From:Migra matters - Progressive Immigration Reform

Display:
I have been following this story..via the diaries on  dKos.  I am still amazed at the amateurishness of the letter/paper trail. Seems like a set-up to me. But, on the other hand, it does expose the suspected network/money trail.

by avahome on Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 09:17:40 AM EST
At his press conference last night, Tan Nguyen  blamed the "hysteria" on a bad translation and declared that he was remaining in the race, rehiring the staffer who "wrote" the letter and furthermore he claimed that polls showed he was going to win.

by Rebel Girl on Mon Oct 23, 2006 at 10:36:15 AM EST
[ Parent ]
terrific write up on this.  Yes, part of it is business as usual in a county long-run by smug Republican ultra-right thugs - but it's also linked to the rise of the anti-immigrant right.

Also of note though is Tom Fuentes' recent appointment by Denny Hastert himself to the national Elections Assistance Commission - exterememly distrubing considering his past and present.

check out our own local coverage of Fuentes as Nugyen's campaign advisor:

http://dissenttheblog.blogspot.com/2006/10/tom-fuentes-campaign-advis_116127373266402036.html

Fuentes' appointment to the Election Assisstance Commission:

http://dissenttheblog.blogspot.com/2006/08/well-respected-individual_29.html

We endure Fuentes as a trustee on our local college baord. Last year he tried to cancel a study abroad program in Spain because Spain had pulled out of Iraq.  You can't amke this stuff up though you wish you could.

Glad to have found you.  Keep up the good work.  I'll visit again.


by Rebel Girl on Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 02:09:53 PM EST

Thanks for the great links... you might be interested in Duke's earlier piece on the Minute Man founder in OC

and welcome!

by Cho on Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 02:14:03 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Thanks - I am still a bit new to the blogosphere - so I appreciate the link.

by Rebel Girl on Fri Oct 20, 2006 at 03:15:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]
Nobody seems willing to post the most important part of this letter.  The first 2 paragraphs of the letter say:

You are being sent this letter because you were recently registered to vote. If you are a citizen of the United States, we ask that you participate in the democratic process of voting.

You are advised that if your residence in this country is illegal or you are an immigrant,voting in a federal election is a crime that could result in jail time, and you will be deported for voting without having a right to do so.  

Click on the link to the letter & see for yourself. Why did you leave it out? If you want to condemn a political tactic, OK, but be honest!!

by Wiley Freeman on Mon Oct 23, 2006 at 01:07:12 PM EST

The word "immigrant" is the problem: it is inappropriate term for the context.  The word "immigrant" includes undocumented people, residents with greeen cards - and yes, naturalized citizens with full voting rights.

The letter was sent to 14,000 people with "Sapnish" surnames, including one elected official - a city councilperson in Santa Ana.

It was printed on the letterhead of a local anti-immigrant group (used without their knowledge) and was signed  (apparently)  by a fictional person (Sergio Ramirez).

The letter also included fraudlent informtion that intended to intimidate.

If Tan Nguyen supports this letter and its contents and its intended audience - as he now says he is - why didn't he put it out on his own letterhead and sign his name?

by Rebel Girl on Mon Oct 23, 2006 at 11:13:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]

when I clicked on the link... indeed the online PDF version of letter says (with the missing paragraph in bold:
You are being sent this letter because you were recently registered to vote. If you are a citizen of the United States, we ask that you participate in the democratic process of voting.

You are advised that if your residence in this country is illegal or you are an immigrant,voting in a federal election is a crime that could result in jail time, and you will be deported for voting without having a right to do so.  

At the same time, you are advised that the government of the United States is installing a new computer system to verify the names of all new registered voters that vote in the October and November elections. Anti-immigration organizations can ask for information from this new computer system.



by Cho on Mon Oct 23, 2006 at 01:37:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]
It is difficult to follow your reasoning Rebel Girl. Since the first paragraph invited the recipient to vote if he or she is a citizen, it clears up any ambiguity about the term "immigrant" in the second paragraph.  This is what keeps the letter from being illegal and why nobody will ever be convicted of any crime because of it.

I do not agree with you definition of immigrant as including naturalized citizens.  Common and ordinary usage is what governs any legal determination of a word, not some strained definition especially when a crime can only be made out by using the strained definition.  Wikipedia defines immigrant as a non-citizen.  When immigrants' rights are mentioned they are not talking about naturalized citizens.

Are you saying that hispanic are not educated enough to know they are citizens after they previously immigrated?  That is hard be believe.  Applicants for citizenship have to take and pass a test to be sure they know their rights and obligations in this country, including the right to vote.

LOOK -- Lets cut to the chase. Voting by ineligible hispanics has been documented in the past in this district.  I think this letter may have helped address the lack of confidence in election outcomes because of suspicions that illegal voting continues.

So, Rebel Girl, I propose the following be sent in a letter to all voters and posted at the polling place:

IF YOU ARE A US CITIZEN YOU CAN VOTE NO MATTER WHERE YOUR WERE BORN.  IF YOU ARE NOT A CITIZEN YOU COULD BE PUNISHED FOR VOTING.

Could you agree with this statement?

by Wiley Freeman on Tue Oct 24, 2006 at 04:07:46 PM EST

The actual word in dispute is "emigrado".  It seems that the word was correctly used in the letter afterall.  So far every Hispanics I've spoken to explains that "emigrado" is an immigrant who is a green card holder.  An emigrado does have legal residency but cannot vote because he/she is not a citizen.

If the letter had used "immigrante" then there would be a big problem.  "Immigrante" does not have any legal connotation and is commonly used to refer to both green card holders AND those who has become citizens.  

Interesting fact, in two of its articles the Spanish newspaper La Opinion replaced the word "emigrado" with "immigrante" when quoting the letter.  Why not just print the whole letter as is for everyone to see?
http://www.laopinion.com/primerapagina/?rkey=00000000000000657540
http://www.laopinion.com/primerapagina/?rkey=00000000000000650880

I think you're right, Wiley.  There won't be any arrest.  This case won't hold up in court.


by tyronebiggums on Thu Oct 26, 2006 at 09:14:00 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I find everything that's been writing about Tan Nguyen quite humorous.  The guy is really not a neo-racist, movement racsit, or a racist period.  I know the guy personally.  We were co-workers a few years ago.  What he really is, is an opportunist and perhaps just a tool.  

Before he ran for office the first time 2 years ago he was not political at all.  He never talked about politics and I don't think he even voted before that.  Just out of the blue one day he quitted his job and decided to run for office because a business partner of his, who'd held public office before, convinced him to and became his campaign manager.  Tan knew absolutely nothing about running for public office.  His big motivation was to become the first Vietnamese congressman in history.  That's what he told everybody.

Two years ago he ran as a Democrats.  He couldn't get any endorsement or help from the party because no one knows who he is.  So he ran the campaign pretty much on his own with just the help of friends and family.  He was going door to door trying to get anyone he could to vote for him.  That included Hispanics and everyone else.  Yes, I said Hispanics.  Unfortunately he didn't get pass the primary.  However, he was very much encouraged by finishing second in a three way race.  So he decided to run again.

This time he chose the 47th district because it supposedly has the highest concentration of Vietnamese, which, I'm guessing, would be a big advantage to him.  He can't run as a Democrat because there is already someone named Loretta Sanchez, who's been the incumbent for 10 years.  On the other hand, the Republican party had no one to really challenge Sanchez and had pretty much given up on the 47th district.  So Tan decided to run as a Republican thinking that he would have a much better chance getting out of the primary.  (He was right.)  He ran into the same problem he did two years ago.  He couldn't get anyone from the party to endorse and help him strategically and with fund raising because, again, nobody really knows him and perhaps because he switched party in a matter of a few months after he lost the first time.  He was on his own again.  Since none of the mainstream republicans is willing to endorse him, he had to look for help elsewhere.  Basically, he met one radical right Republican guy who's willing to endorse him and the whole thing sort of snowballed from there.  The rest is history.  

To sum it up, the radical right Republicans found a soldier to fight their battle for them, someone who's naive when it comes to the dirty games of politics.  They endorse him, organize fund raising events for him.  In return, he does what they plan for him.

Tan's a very nice and friendly guy when you get to know him personally.  Too bad he's gotten himself in such a bad situation by listenning to bad advices.  You guys may find it hard to believe but he's actually very sympathetic to Mexican immigrants.  It is because when he first came to the US he and his parents were farm workers themselves working alongside Mexicans.  It is in his bio on his website.

People do change so I might be wrong but I'm pretty sure he's not a racist.

by tyronebiggums on Wed Oct 25, 2006 at 09:57:46 AM EST

the day this story first broke I was contacted by two unrelated sources who informed me of the fact that they had seen Nguyen post comments over at the SOS forum chat boards. Independently, they each stated that they had been monitoring him on the board for a while.

The day the story broke his posts were scrubbed. ( which is a common occurrence at SOS as seen in this previous case)

It was these two reports that led me to investigate Nguyens ties to SOS.

Due to your assertions about Nguyen, my sources are now trying to find cached versions of the posts. If and when we find them I will post them here.

For the record the two sources that contacted me regularly monitor the forums of SOS, National Alliance , Stormfront etc. and I have no reason to believe that their claims would be untrue. But since it could not be verified at the time of publication of the story that Nguyen had personally posted on the site, I did not include it in the story.


by Duke1676 on Wed Oct 25, 2006 at 09:15:50 PM EST
[ Parent ]

So are you telling me that two sources had seen Nguyen, with their own eyes, post comments over at SOS?  Or do you mean two sources had seen comments posted over at SOS by someone who they think is Nguyen?  Be specific.  

Even if your sources can find "cached versions" of the posts, it doesn't "prove" anything.  I could, then, make the accusation that your sources concocted the whole thing.  And just because the posts were scrubbed, so what?  Unless you have a witness who'd seen him do it with his/her own eyes or you have him recorded on video while he's doing it, you have nothing.  And you shouldn't make such an assumption.

Am I really Tyrone Biggums?  Can you prove whether I am or am not?  No, you can't.  Anybody can pretends to be or appears to be anyone on the internet.  

All that aside, the purpose of my post was to give everyone an inside take on the real Tan Nguyen from someone who knows the guy personally.  I'm telling you he is just as much a Republican or racist as he was a Democrat two years ago.  I'm not at all surprise and don't blame anyone for being skeptical considering how he has been running his campaign.  But you don't have to take my words for it.  Time will tell.  When this election is all over with, if Nguyen would be attending any future meeting with SOS, CCIR, Minuteman, etc. I'm sure your sources will promptly report to you.

by tyronebiggums on Thu Oct 26, 2006 at 12:06:40 AM EST
[ Parent ]

just as his campaign manager did.(including the phone number for the Tan Nguyen for Congress Offices)

This was back in July long before this scandal broke  so I don't think someone purposely put up false posts back then hoping that Nguyen would later mess up and open himself to accusations of racism.

He, just like his campaign manager courted the members of SOS ...perhaps he was unaware of their ties to white supremacists, or perhaps believed their assertions that they are just a group of true patriots and nothing more. But the fact remains there's proof positive his manager was there... as to Nguyen himself ...it's to be seen.

by Duke1676 on Thu Oct 26, 2006 at 02:59:16 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Will you be writing a follow-up?

by Cho on Fri Oct 27, 2006 at 01:22:04 PM EST
[ Parent ]
A week ago Bill Lockyer, California's Attorney General seized the computers in Tan Nguyen's campaign office and home under a search warrant. He promised arrests would be forthcoming. Nothing has happened so far except that he has kept the computers. How long does it legitimately take to search a computer?  My computer tech says that with the resources of the Attorney General's office, one day would be enough.

A week ago, California Secretary of State, Bruce McPherson informed the public that he had top investigators in the area and pledged that they would report if any law had been broken.  Nothing has happened so far except that he sent out a letter on official State of California letterhead which also contained the logos of La Raza, MALDEF, and some other latino organization.  Then, of course, we have Arnold the Brainless and his "this is a hate crime comment."

The letter from McPherson might as well have been an endorsement of Loretta Sanchez.  Why else would Mr. McPherson put latino organizations logos on an official letter from the State of California in a race between a latina and a Vietnamese?  Why has there been no arrests or statements by Attorney General Lockyer or McPherson about what crime if any was committed?

The answer - There has been no crime committed!!  Oh yes, it appears that the Nguyen campaign engaged in speech that Lockyer, McPherson, La Raza and some others "hate to hear" but that is not "hate speech."  The message - If you are not a citizen, you can't vote - is legitimate and lawful.

It now appears that these same public officials may have broken federal election law.  Specifically, 18 USC §245(b)(1)(A) makes it a crime to willfully interfere with a candidate during a campaign through force whether or not under color of law. Taking Mr. Nguyen's computer and keeping them robs him of the ability to campaign in a meaningful way.  Slandering him but not let him confront the so-called crimes is like running campaign commercials against him.

This is not over.  Regardless of who wins the chickens will come home to roost for more people than Nguyen.

by Wiley Freeman on Thu Oct 26, 2006 at 06:28:40 PM EST

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |