Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


The "Ethics" of New Orleans Reporting

by rcs1

retagged for Ethics discussion and Front page

The pictures streaming through our televisons and plastered across our newspapers remind many people of third world countries. "This is America. This isn't supposed to happen here" say both refugees and their fellow Americans around the country. The worst aspect of this is the looting that plagues New Orleans. Gunfights are breaking out. This morning there were reports of an explosion at a paint factory (why you would loot a paint factory, I can't understand).

The newspapers have done an admirable job in covering the details of the story. What they have not covered so well are the failures of the Bush administration in preparing for this (very possible) catastrophe.  While it is true that they have, to a certain extent, covered the inability for FEMA and others to act on a threat they knew about, they have not given front-page coverage to why such a disaster has never happened before. In addition, they have not looked terribly fairly at the root causes of the looting, or at the racial aspects of it.


ethics :: :: :: buzz-it!
Let me quickly discuss the looting. It's sad, but predictable that the looting would happen. It's a mentality that has been fueled by desperation, group psychology, and the already terrible situation of many of New Orleans's poor. Those who have read Lord of the Flies or Shirley Jackson's story The Lottery can find parallels in the group psychology. Only today are we starting to see front page coverage focusing on the racial and economical imbalance of the dead and victims. There were hints for days along the lines of "many of these people did not have the means to leave." There was little that I saw or read that explained that line. Perhaps I missed things, and if I did, please feel free to let me know. More importantly, you will find several pictures where whites are "finding" food floating in the water, while blacks are "looting" that food. Take from that what you will.

On the other hand, I have been searching in vain for a public discussion of the natural contributors to the disaster: the loss of the wetlands protection (mentioned a few times) and globabl warming (stuck on the editorial pages). Several editorials have pointed out that the strength of hurricanes has increased and will continue to increase with global warming, which the administration has ignored. But putting that point in an editorial means that only those who are sympathetic with the paper's point of view (often a liberal one in this case). The same goes for how the disappearance of the wetlands buffer strengthened the force of the hurricane that hit New Orleans. The only news story I've seen focusing on these things was a report on the German environmental minister's comments in the back pages of the Washington Post. It should be a primary concern of the media to enlighten the public on just how this hurricane was so strong. Instead, they decide that they'll ignore any possible political ties and report the other stories. These deserve just as much coverage, but I hope to see better coverage of the envrionmental factors, so that Americans can actually learn something from this tragedy.

Display:
The media has failed miserably to provide any useful information.  With the resources available to the industry as a whole there is not one single news source with a list of exactly what resources are available for the people in the path of Katrina.

Did you know that 9000 utility workers are both on site and streaming in from all over the country to rebuild the grid?  That an Air Force rapid response team is setting up an airport in Gulf Port?  That the secretary of labor just put $50 million out there to hire 10,000 people, with preference for locals?  Why bother to ask or publish when there are dead people in the water?

What units, from which agencies/companies, with what strength, capability, supplies, time-to-location, are available where?

If you find the answer to that multiple-part question let me know.  Had that information been available - pushed for - two days ago, the temperature level in this country might be just a bit lower.

The information is out there, but still not available from a single source.  That failure belongs to the media.  None dare care it news.

by rba on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 03:28:18 PM EST

I agree that information would be very useful.  I wonder if they are even that organized yet.  I have the impression they are still in the process of coordinating and couldn't even provide the answer to those questions.

by standingup on Fri Sep 02, 2005 at 08:02:21 PM EST
[ Parent ]
site has situation reports (took awhile to find them):  

http://www.fema.gov/emanagers

Also news releases.  Hide in (not-so) plain sight.  Decent information - not comprehensive, but helpful.

by rba on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 02:08:58 AM EST
[ Parent ]



by intranets on Sat Sep 03, 2005 at 02:41:54 AM EST

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |