Subscribe to ePluribus Media



ePluribus Media Store


Want Headlines via Email?
Enter your email address:


Help Save 1.800.SUICIDE


The Neglected Political Power of Story

by rcs1

Cindy Sheehan's quest for an interview with the president has captured the attention of a nation. For the first time in a long time, liberals have an edge on leading the national conversation. Trouble is, they don't understand why and they don't understand how it happened, so they are going to continue to be mired in the gibberish produced by think tanks and policy analysis, thus boring the electorate shitless and losing attention. Want to keep the advantage we've briefly experienced with Sheehan?

It's very simple: We are a storytelling species. Tell some goddamned gripping stories that illustrate our world view.

This is different from "framing," mind you (a phrase I'm coming to loathe, no matter how useful). Framing addresses how to name and slant specific policy stances and issues. Narrative illustrates the specific consequences of policy - and propel interest along through a process of plot, which encompasses characters, conflict, action, growth and ultimate outcome.


commentary :: :: :: buzz-it!
Human beings want to make sense of a chaotic and superficially meaningless universe, and our brains are consequently programmed to respond to a story arc; it's how nearly all of our cultural information and our world views are passed on. Even when we are telling of the events of our mundane day at the dinner table, we unconsciously use the age-old structure of narrative: beginning, middle, end (or Act I, Act II, Act III), with the punch of a climax built into the end. (See David Mamet's superb Three Uses of the Knife to learn more about the structure of daily storytelling.)

We respond to narrative the same way we respond to cocaine: We simply can't get enough of it. We want more and more and more. That's why there's Homer's Odyssey, Shakespeare's plays, the Bible and the Koran, reality TV, comic books, the Academy Awards and soap operas (the latter proving quality execution doesn't even matter ... just feed us some drama. Now. Fast. We'll take crack if cocaine ain't arround). That's why there's interest in Cindy Sheehan.

That's also why the right has gained so much traction in the national conversation: they tell a good story. Terry Schiavo, Bush the recovering alcoholic kickass cowboy, liberals are killing Christmas and on and on and on.

Good versus evil, the small versus the mighty ... suspense, heroes, adventures, action - and in Sheehan's case, the ultimate storyline of all storylines ... the noble quest. Get the hang of how to use this structure, and you've got yourself a podium with this nation.

Don't get me wrong. There's still a need for liberal policy institutes and think tanks to pore over polls, spot economic trends, analyze the statistical impact of proposed legislation. But dumping the resultant reports on the public without giving it a coherent narrative is going to bind us to the "ivory tower academic" image forever - and it's going to glaze our collective eyes over in the process.

In my view, it's better strategy to nurture some decent middlemen (or "middlepersons" for the PC crowd) who can tell a decent story - some talented fiction writers and playwrights and screenplay writers - to write press releases and blog interesting stories into the mainstream. Creative writers have the additional advantage of being cheap; "will write for food" is pretty much the motto of anyone trying to break into the fiction/screenplay market.

I was going to use this diary to go into details about the necessary specific elements of pure story and how to use them to best advantage in the political realm, but this is already long enough. If there's any interest, I'll pursue it in future diaries. If not, I'll let it die a natural death.

Display:

...there is a need to develop a good fact base, but without context, the facts are and remain inert.  Weave them into the narrative of a good yarn, and they leap to their feet and dance an intoxicating tarentella that leaves listeners with  spinning heads and racing hearts.

We are, after all, human beings, and every human being is playing the hero's role in story of their life.  Therefore we know structure instinctly and can respond to other's victories and defeats.

In a more specific example, when I was looking for an approach to tell the details of what I found in Crawford, I briefly considered a "Just the facts" piece, but settled on telling the story of the journey and the stories of those I met along the way.  

In the end, they were more compelling to write and, hopefully, more powerful to read.

We can and should do this in the political realm as well.

Well done, ePM.


by NYBri on Fri Aug 19, 2005 at 12:42:08 PM EST

Susan G, I just found out who you are.  Been reading your posts at Kos and here.  My dad called me after speaking to you the other day.  Great to see you involved like this.  Your commentary is quite insightful.  To contact me my email address is mylastname@comcast.net.  I think you'll be able to figure that one out.  Just in case you can't, San Diego, friend of Matt's.

by mohigan on Fri Aug 19, 2005 at 04:45:54 PM EST
I couldn't believe it when I talked to your dad the other day. I was waiting after that call for you to pop up somewhere since he said you were an avid Kos reader yourself and had steered him there.

Small world, eh?

I'll be in touch soon.

by SusanG on Fri Aug 19, 2005 at 05:03:57 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Susan...I don't want this thought/pic to go away!

The power of a story, yes...but words paint a picture. And a question: How will they attach this grieving mother?

http://stevegilliard.blogspot.com/2005/08/cruelty-is-new-black.html

"The GOP has taken refuge in cruelty as politics.

I've wondered for a while why so many conservatives have made a sport of being cruel to Cindy Sheehan. As if losing her son wasn't enough cruelty."

by avahome on Sun Aug 21, 2005 at 10:07:13 AM EST

Support ePluribus Media -- Support Citizen Powered Journalism!

ePluribus Media

↑ Grab this Headline Animator

members


community front page

make a new account


Username:
Password:

create account | faq | search | community front page |